by
Damien
F. Mackey
From Gaza [Egyptian G3-d3-tw], to Yehem
[Egyptian Y-hm],
via a narrow defile, Aruna [Egyptian '3-rw-n3],
to Megiddo [Egyptian My-k-ty]. So it goes.
Introduction
The
high official Senenmut, often described as ‘the power behind the throne’ of the
Eighteenth Dynasty pharaohs, Hatshepsut and Thutmose III, was -
according to my now very strong conviction - none other than King Solomon of
Israel himself, lately most heavily involved also in Egyptian affairs.
Senenmut,
as Solomon, as we read in my article:
Solomon and Sheba
faded
from the Egyptian scene in about Year 16 of these Egyptian co-rulers.
If
this was the approximate time of Senenmut’s-Solomon’s death, then the 5th
year of his son, Rehoboam, the year when Shishak king of Egypt came up against
Jerusalem and pillaged its Temple and palace:
I Kings
14:25-26: “In the fifth
year of King Rehoboam, Shishak king of Egypt attacked Jerusalem. He carried off the
treasures of the Temple of the Lord and the
treasures of the royal palace. He took everything, including all the gold
shields Solomon had made” ….
must coincide very
closely indeed to Thutmose III’s First Campaign in his Year 22-23, the
very military campaign that Dr. Immanuel Velikovsky had identified with the
biblical one (Ages in Chaos, I, 1952).
Since I have fully
accepted Dr. Velikovsky’s identification of Thutmose III as the biblical
“Shishak king of Egypt”, I
therefore have something of a vested interest in his estimation that the
pharaoh’s First Campaign was the biblical episode. Chronologically, in
my revised scheme (Senenmut-Solomon factor), it fits like a glove.
But
what about geographically?
Well,
that has turned out to be a monumental challenge.
The
campaign as conventionally explained
We
are going to be looking at four differing geographies for pharaoh
Thutmose III’s First Campaign, the last three of these will be revised
views.
I
refer to these four:
·
The
conventional account of it;
·
Dr. I.
Velikovsky’s account of it;
·
Dr. E.
Danelius’s account of it;
·
My own
view.
·
Conventional
Apart
from its being dated approximately half a millennium too early on the time
scale (c. 1460 BC instead of c. 920 BC), the conventional estimation of the
geography of at least the early stage of the First Campaign of Thutmose
III does not accord at all with the Egyptian description of it topographically
speaking.
All
reconstructions (whether conventional or revised) are in agreement that the
Egyptian army first marched to the city of Gaza.
Wikipedia
briefly tells of how the
conventional version of the campaign runs in its article, “Thutmose III”:
First Campaign
Thutmose III smiting his enemies. Relief on the seventh pylon
in Karnak
When Hatshepsut died on the 10th day of
the sixth month of Thutmose III's 21st year, according to information from a
single stela from Armant,
the king of Kadesh advanced
his army to Megiddo. …. Thutmose III mustered his own army and departed
Egypt, passing through the border fortress of Tjaru (Sile)
on the 25th day of the eighth month. Thutmose marched his troops through the
coastal plain as far as Jamnia,
then inland to Yehem, a small city near Megiddo, which he reached in the middle
of the ninth month of the same year. ….
The ensuing Battle of Megiddo probably was the largest battle of
Thutmose's 17 campaigns. A ridge of mountains jutting inland from Mount Carmel stood
between Thutmose and Megiddo and he had three potential routes to take. ….
The northern route and the southern
route, both of which went around the mountain, were judged by his council of
war to be the safest, but Thutmose, in an act of great bravery (or so he
boasts, but such self-praise is normal in Egyptian texts), accused the council
of cowardice and took a dangerous route … through the Aruna mountain
pass, which he alleged was only wide enough for the army to pass "horse
after horse and man after man." ….
Despite the laudatory nature of
Thutmose's annals, such a pass does indeed exist, although not as narrow as
Thutmose indicates … and taking it was a brilliant strategic
move since when his army emerged from the pass they were situated on the plain
of Esdraelon, directly between the rear of the Canaanite forces and Megiddo
itself. ….
For some reason, the Canaanite forces did
not attack him as his army emerged … and his army routed them decisively.
….The size of the two forces is difficult to determine, but if, as Redford
suggests, the amount of time it took to move the army through the pass may be
used to determine the size of the Egyptian force, and if the number of sheep
and goats captured may be used to determine the size of the Canaanite force,
then both armies were around 10,000 men. ….
Most scholars believe that the Egyptian army was more numerous.
….
According to Thutmose III's Hall of
Annals in the Temple of Amun at Karnak, the battle occurred on "Year
23, I Shemu [day] 21, the exact day of the feast of the new moon" … a
lunar date. This date corresponds to 9 May 1457 BC based on Thutmose III's
accession in 1479 BC. After victory in battle, his troops stopped to
plunder the enemy and the enemy was able to escape into Megiddo. ….
Thutmose was forced to besiege the city,
but he finally succeeded in conquering it after a siege of seven or eight
months ….
This campaign drastically changed the
political situation in the ancient Near East. By taking Megiddo, Thutmose
gained control of all of northern Canaan and
the Syrian princes were obligated to send tribute and their own sons as
hostages to Egypt. …. the Assyrian, Babylonian and Hittite kings
all gave Thutmose gifts, which he alleged to be "tribute" when he
recorded it on the walls of Karnak. ….
[End of quote]
From
Gaza [Egyptian G3-d3-tw], to Yehem [Egyptian Y-hm],
via a narrow defile, Aruna [Egyptian '3-rw-n3], to Megiddo
[Egyptian My-k-ty].
So it goes.
Then
the pharaoh will go on to invade Syria, and, ultimately, on to Syrian Kadesh
[Egyptian Kd-šw].
This
conventional reconstruction of the campaign, if correct, would absolutely
shatter any consideration that this could have been the biblical episode
involving Jerusalem and the pharaoh Shishak. Prior to Megiddo, the route almost
entirely hugs the coast.
At
least it does not go anywhere near inland Jerusalem.
Thankfully,
the conventional effort can be shown to be hopelessly inadequate as to its
reconstruction of the early part of the campaign.
Dr.
Eva Danelius has shattered it - and indeed a crucial part of Dr. Velikovsky’s
reconstruction as well (see below) - in her brilliant article, “Did Thutmose
III Despoil the Temple in Jerusalem? A Critical Commentary to Chapter IV of
"Ages in Chaos".” (SIS Review, v2, No.3, 1977/78).
While her main achievement here was on the level of topography,
her comments about some key name identifications were also most
telling.
Writing of the infamous Aruna road, for instance, Dr.
Danelius tells how the conventional identification of the location by no means
fits the actual name:
Breasted identified this defile, the
road called "Aruna" in Egyptian records, with the Wadi 'Ara which
connects the Palestine maritime plain with the Valley of Esdraelon .... It was
this identification which aroused my curiosity, and my doubt. …. As an
afterthought, Nelson [see below] warns not to be deceived by the Arabic name
(wadi) 'Ara: "Etymologically, it seems hardly possible to equate
(Egyptian) 'Aruna with (Arab) 'Ar'arah." ….
But Eva
Danelius had a problem far more serious with the conventional identification of
the Aruna road than this one of etymology - one which really had
‘aroused her doubt’. Thus she explains:
If it is true that "the geography of a country
determines the course of its wars" … the frightful defile, and attempts at
its crossing by conquering armies, should have been reported in books of
Biblical and/or post-Biblical history. There is no mention of either. Nor has
the Wadi 'Ara pass ever been considered to be secret, or dangerous.
"From the Plain of Sharon to Jordan. This
line... ascends by the broad and open valley Wâdy 'Ârah, crossing the watershed
at Ain Ibrahim, which is about 1200 feet above the sea. Thence the road
descends, falling some 700 feet in 3 miles to Lejjûn, where it bifurcates ....
This line, which appears to be ancient, is of great importance, being one
of the easiest across the country, owing to the open character of
Wâdy 'Ârah." This was written 100 years ago, by C. R. Conder … long before
a modern highway was laid through.
Conder's view is shared by later writers:
"Most armies coming north over Sharon ... would cut across the ... hills
by the easy passes which issue on Esdraelon at Megiddo and
elsewhere." - thus, a famous historian and geographer ….
The last army which actually crossed by this pass
on its way from the south was the Egyptian Expeditionary Force under General
Allenby, in September 1918. General Wavell evaluates the difficulties of the
crossing when discussing the operational plan for the final onslaught:
"There was no obstacle to rapid movement along either the Plain of Sharon
or Plain of Esdraelon. The crux of the ride would be the passage of the
mountain belt which divides these two plains... the width of this obstacle is
about seven miles.
Two routes lead across it from Sharon, of which...
the eastern debouches into Esdraelon at El Lejjûn or Megiddo .... Neither road
presents any physical difficulties for a mounted force.
On the other hand, either is easy of defence and
would be hard to force against opposition." On September19th, 1918, a
brigade with armoured cars was sent ahead to seize the defile leading to El
Lejjûn. It was undefended, and on the following night "the 4th Cavalry
Division passed the Musmus Defile (Wadi 'Ara pass) during the night, after some
delay due to a loss of direction by the leading brigade, and reached the plain
at El Lejjûn by dawn." ….
During the same years in which Breasted wrote his
reconstruction of the campaign, a German team under Schuhmacher started to
excavate Tell el-Mutesellim. The excavation was carried out during the years
1903 to 1905. Unfortunately, "At the spot excavated by Schuhmacher,
absolutely nothing has been found which could provide any further
information" (concerning identification of the mound with that besieged,
and conquered, by Thutmose III), states the report ….
Schuhmacher's excavation was much too limited to
permit final judgement. Breasted, quite rightly, refused to give up so easily.
He wanted scientific proof for his identification, and suggested to one of his
students, Harold H. Nelson, that he dedicate his doctoral thesis to the
problem. Nelson was not given freedom to look for the frightening defile among
the mountains of Palestine; Breasted confined him to a specific region:
"This study is confined almost entirely to an effort to interpret the Annals
of Thutmose III in the light of the geography of the environs of Megiddo,"
explains Nelson in his preface …. In other words, the "scientific
investigation" had to verify a foregone conclusion of Breasted - it was
"prove or perish" for the unhappy young man.
For the sensitive reader, the resulting
dissertation is a moving testimony of an intelligent and honest young student
who tried desperately to harmonise the theory of his venerated teacher with the
observations made on the spot, which simply did not fit.
Nelson travelled through the Wadi 'Ara pass in
1909, and again in 1912. He described it in detail: '... the road enters the
Wady 'Ara which is there ... flat and open ... All the way to a quarter of a
mile above 'Ar'arah the valley is wide and level and cultivated up the slopes
on either side ... the ascent is so gradual as to be scarcely perceptible and
it is possible to drive a carriage as far as the top of the pass." The
road follows an ancient Roman road which descends along a smaller way.
"This latter gradually contracts as it proceeds till about half a mile
above the mouth of the valley, it reaches its narrowest point, being not more
than 10 yards wide. A little further on the road ... opening out rapidly to a
couple of 100 yards, emerges upon the plain of Lejjûn."
Nelson comes to the conclusion that:
"Of course such a road could be easily
defended by a comparatively small number of men, but, on the other hand, an
invading army could readily keep possession of the hills on either hand which
are neither steep nor high above the valley ... a watcher posted on the hill
above Lejjûn could descry an approaching army at least a mile above the mouth
of the pass."
….
Neither the physical appearance of the road as
described by Nelson, nor its use as an international highway justify its
identification with a road described as "inaccessible",
"secret" or "mysterious" in the Egyptian records.
[End of quotes]
This
telling estimation by Dr. Danelius has stuck with me even as I have vacillated
from one viewpoint to another about the actual route of the First Campaign, at
one stage even dropping Dr. Velikovsky’s view that it was the biblical “Shishak”
episode and so looking for a more appropriate campaign by Thutmose III.
Eventually,
though, I would have to find a solution that was in topographical
harmony with the Egyptian account.
Dr.
Danelius was also critical of the conventional interpretation of the place
named in the Egyptian Annals as Y-hm.
Though I never
considered her alternative explanation of it, as ‘Yamnia (Yabne in Hebrew)’, to be very convincing either, and had wondered
if a better solution for Y-hm was possible.
More recently, I have
come to the conclusion that Y-hm is the key to the entire
situation. That Y-hm refers to Jerusalem!
This is what Dr.
Danelius herself had to say about this Y-hm:
Let us stop here and survey the situation. To
recapitulate: the one undisputed place reached by the Egyptian army was Gaza.
From there on, every "identification" has been pure guesswork. This
is especially true for the "identification" of Y-hm,
which was supposed to have been near the entrance to Wadi 'Ara (and identified,
eventually, with Jemma, a nearby Arab village). In order to reach this place,
the army which had just crossed the Sinai desert would have continued marching
for 10 days, covering about 90 English miles …. So far Breasted, and his
followers to this day.
Experience has shown that an army which includes
cavalry and chariots drawn by horses cannot progress that quickly in a country
where drinking water is in short supply during the dry season, May to November.
It seems that neither Breasted nor any of his followers has given any thought
to this vital question, not to mention other problems of logistics. In this
respect, the dispatches sent by General Allenby to the Secretary of State for
War during the advance of the Forces in the Philistine Plain are a veritable
eye-opener. Gaza had fallen on November 7th 1917. Two days later: "By the
9th, the problem became one of supply ... the question of water and forage was
a very difficult one.
Even where water was found in sufficient
quantities, it was usually in wells and not on the surface, and consequently...
the process of watering a large quantity of animals was slow and
difficult," writes Allenby (90). The very next day, November 10th:
"The hot wind is an additional trial, particularly to the cavalry already
suffering from water-shortage." (This was near Ashdod, in the Philistine
Plain.) "Owing to the exhaustion of their horses on account of the lack of
water", two mounted brigades "had to be withdrawn into reserve"
on November 11th.
There is no reason to suppose that nature was
kinder to Thutmose's troops in May, the month with the greatest number of days
with the destructive hot wind blowing from the desert. than to the Allied
troops in November.
Allenby's advance, too, was considerably slower
than that demanded in Breasted's calendar for the advance of the Pharaoh's
army: the Allied left wing covered only 40 miles in 15 days along the plain … while Breasted suggested 80-90 miles in 10-11
days.
These observations may justify a totally different
interpretation of the events during the 10 or 11 days from the day Thutmose
left Gaza to the council of war at Y-hm.
According to the unanimous understanding of
Egyptologists, the text of the Annals leaves no doubt that the
entrance into Gaza was a peaceful one. There is no hint of any resistance by
the inhabitants. Gaza, in the10th century BC, was the seat of one of the five
Philistine kings …. The peaceful entry and exit of the Pharaoh and his army
justifies the assumption that the Egyptians found themselves in a friendly
country. War preparations by the Pharaoh, most probably, were not confined to
the purely military side; they should have included political discussions with
the countries bordering the Judaean Kingdom: Edom, Philistia and the newly
created Kingdom of Israel. Among these, the Philistine Plain would be the ideal
base for an army considering the conquest of Judah and Jerusalem. For the
following, it is assumed that the Egyptians were in the position to use it as
such ….
The place named immediately after Gaza is Y-hm.
Petrie suggested an identification with the modern
Arab village Yemma, south-west of the Carmel ridge, an identification that is
"little more than guesswork" according to Nelson ….
If an eminent Egyptologist like Petrie thought an
equation Y-hm = Yemma possible, it may be permitted to see
in Y-hm the Egyptian equivalent of Yamnia (Yabne in Hebrew), a
port about 40 km north of Gaza. Today, Yamnia/Yabne lies about 7 km inland from
the Mediterranean, from which it is separated by a broad belt of sand dunes.
The plain around it is strewn with the remnants of Bronze Age and Iron Age
settlements, among them a harbour town at the mouth of a little river which
bypasses the city.
Needless to say, possession of a harbour would
facilitate the problem of supply and help considerably in its solution. It is
suggested to see in Yamnia the location of the campaign base and council of war
described in the Annals ….
[End of quotes]
For conventional history, any
reconstruction of pharaoh Thutmose III is going to be out by some 500 years.
That, for one, negates any
possibility of his being the biblical “Shishak king of Egypt”, and it also
negates any of his many campaigns as being the famous biblical attack on
Jerusalem.
Apart from some flawed name connections, especially the hopeless
equation of the Egyptian Aruna (most crucial in any reconstruction of
the event) with Wadi ‘Ara (Arab) ‘Ar‘arah, the conventional site for Aruna, Wadi ‘Ara, cannot possibly be associated topographically with
the notorious road as described with such dread by the Egyptian soldiery. And
this, despite Wikipedia’s hopeful “… such a pass does indeed
exist, although not as narrow as Thutmose indicates”.
The
campaign as Dr. Velikovsky explained it
Most ironic that Dr. Velikovsky, to whom we must be forever
grateful for his
having courageously revised Eighteenth Dynasty Egypt on
a massive scale,
would contribute nothing really worthwhile regarding the route
taken by
pharaoh Thutmose III, the biblical Shishak, in his First
Campaign,
the one that Velikovsky had correctly identified as the
biblical episode.
For
once we find Dr. Immanuel Velikovsky following the conventional view for the
early part of Thutmose III’s First Campaign, and thus getting things
quite wrong – as according to what we learned above of the conventional
interpretation.
Dr.
Velikovsky had accepted professor Breasted’s view that Megiddo was the Mk-t-y
of the Egyptian Annals, and that Thutmose III and his troops had followed the
coastal route from Gaza to Megiddo.
That
immediately runs into the serious problem of topographical dissimilarity
as already pointed out. Dr. Velikovsky, when confronted with Dr. Eva Danelius’s
criticism of it, came with this reply that I consider to be weak, no better
really than Wikipedia’s: “… such a pass does indeed exist, although not as
narrow as Thutmose indicates”.
And so Dr. Velikovsky
wrote (“A Response to Eva Danelius”, SIS Review, Vol. II No. 3 Special Issue 1977/78, p.
80):
Now as to the approach to Megiddo being a narrow pass - by what it is
now, it cannot be judged what it was almost three thousand years ago. There
could have been artificial mound-fortifications the length of the pass. Think,
for instance, of Tyre of the time of Shalmaneser III or Nebuchadnezzar (who
besieged it for 13 years), or even of the days of Alexander, when it withstood
a protracted siege. Today its topography is completely changed.
Neither of
these comments (Wikipedia, Velikovsky) does justice to the frightening
description of the Aruna Road as we find in the Egyptian campaign
record.
Having started badly on this one, Dr. Velikovsky then became more
typically interesting and controversial. Instead of the Egyptian campaign now
heading into Syria, as according to professor Breasted and the conventional
view, Dr. Velikovsky has it suddenly wheeling back in dramatic fashion,
southwards to Kadesh - obviously not the Syrian Kadesh, but Jerusalem itself
(Kadesh = the “Holy”) according to Velikovsky.
The Egyptians are now supposedly in pursuit of the fleeing King of
Kadesh, Rehoboam, son of Solomon, heading for sanctuary in his capital city of
Jerusalem.
Exciting stuff, but pure fantasy!
From Megiddo, the Egyptian army was actually on its way northwards towards
Syria, as Creationist Patrick Clarke has clearly demonstrated in his article:
Was
Jerusalem the Kadesh of Thutmose III’s 1st Asiatic campaign?—topographic and
petrographic evidence
It seems that Dr.
Velikovsky - a bit like with that song by The
Who, “north side of my town faced east and the east was facing south” -
had the Egyptian army heading north while it was still located in the south
[see below], and then lurching southwards when it was really heading for the
north.
Most
ironic that Dr. Velikovsky, to whom we must be forever grateful for his having
courageously revised Eighteenth Dynasty Egypt on a massive scale, would
contribute nothing really worthwhile regarding the route taken by pharaoh
Thutmose III, the biblical Shishak, in his First Campaign, the one that
Velikovsky had correctly identified as the biblical episode.
The
campaign as Dr. Danelius explained it
After
my initial, rather uncritical, acceptance of Dr. Velikovsky’s reconstruction in
the early days, I became quite enamoured with Dr. Eva Danelius’s version (“Did
Thutmose III Despoil the Temple in Jerusalem?”), which pointed out problems of
which I had been blissfully unaware, and, seemingly, solved the major ones of
these.
Whilst
I no longer accept her thesis as a whole, Dr. Danelius’s important contribution
in the area of topography, and her connection of Aruna with the
biblical Araunah the Jebusite, hence Jerusalem, remained with me.
I
believe that this element is necessary for a proper resolution of the whole
matter.
Instead
of having the Egyptian army march almost immediately from Gaza towards Megiddo,
but via the broad coastal road (which cannot be correct), Dr Danelius has it
march a far shorter distance northwards to connect with the Beth-horon road
that leads back into Jerusalem.
This
is far more promising than the previous attempts, given that Jerusalem is in
sight from the start, and that the Beth-horon road was notorious for its
steepness and narrowness.
It
is this road, Beth-horon, that Eva Danelius will identify as the unpalatable Aruna
road of the Egyptian Annals.
Whereas
Dr. Velikovsky had tried to identify Jerusalem as Kadesh, but wrongly, now Dr.
Danelius will hopefully identify Jerusalem as Mk-t-y, again wrongly.
She
appears to have based her interpretation of Mk-t-y here on somewhat late
names for the capital city:
Among the names enumerated as designating Jerusalem is
Bait-al-Makdis, or in brief, Makdis, corresponding to Beithha-Miqdash in modern
Hebrew pronunciation. The10th century Arab writer who mentions this name calls
himself Mukadassi = the Jerusalemite …. The name Mâkdes was still used by the
Samaritans (a Jewish sect who never left the country, who trace their ancestors
to three of the northern tribes of Israel) at the beginning of this century,
when discussing with Rabbi Moshe Gaster their attitude towards Jerusalem … and
a local shop outside Damascus Gate still bears the inscription: Baith
el-Makdis.
But
Mk-t-y, in its association in the Annals with Taanach (Egyptian T3-'3-n3-k3),
is clearly Megiddo, as both professor Breasted and Dr. Velikovsky had accepted.
Response
to Eva Danelius: “Taanach is also
next to Megiddo in the Bible (I Kings 4:12). Your equation of Taanach with the
Tahhunah ridge does not strengthen your thesis”.
Good
try, though!
What
we can take from the thesis of Dr. Danelius - and it is not insignificant - is
that the Aruna road really was a steep and forbidding road, and that it
was near to Jerusalem.
But
do we need to go northwards from Gaza to get on to it, only to have to double
back after that?
Or
is there a more simple, Occam’s Razor, procedure?
How,
I think, the campaign needs to be explained
But it seems that there are problems with
every interpretation of the pharaoh’s route.
Can pharaoh Thutmose III be saved as “Shishak”?
The road to salvation is narrow and difficult to find (Matthew 7:14),
and so has been the road to identifying, historically, the biblical “Shishak
king of Egypt” (2 Kings 14:25).
Thutmose III, the mightiest Eighteenth Dynasty pharaoh, had once
opted for a ‘redemption’ type of road, one narrow and most difficult to
negotiate. And his military scribe, Tjaneni, marked down this road using
the name ‘3-rw-n3 (Aruna).
This road’s true identification has been missed by historians,
conventional and revisionist alike.
I say this because those on both sides who have accepted the typical
identification of the Aruna road as the Wãdy ‘Ârah, opening out towards
Taanach and Megiddo, have not been able to explain at all satisfactorily why
the Wãdy ‘Ârah’s topography is nothing like that as described in pharaoh
Thutmose III’s campaign Annals.
Sir Henry Breasted’s prize doctoral student, Harold H. Nelson, had
demonstrated beyond all doubt in his thesis, The Battle of Megiddo
(1913), that the relatively gentle topography in that northern region
did not accord at all with the terrifyingly narrow and steep road described by
the Egyptians, that ‘enters into narrowness’ and where ‘horse will have to go
after horse’.
(References to Harold H. Nelson have been taken from Dr. Eva Danelius’s
“Did Thutmose III Despoil the Temple in Jerusalem?”, SIS Review, Vol. 2
No. 3, 1977/78).
Nor did the name ‘Ârah accord well linguistically with Aruna, as Harold
Nelson had rightly observed: “Etymologically, it seems hardly possible
to equate (Egyptian) ‘Aruna with (Arab) ‘Ar‘arah”.
And, while the young man succeeded in passing his doctorate to the
professor’s satisfaction, Nelson later dissociated himself completely from its
conclusions.
One ought to read Dr. Danelius’s poignant account in her article of
Harold H. Nelson and the fate of his doctoral thesis.
Dr. Eva Danelius herself was the researcher to have come closest to
identifying the Aruna road.
According to her, it must have been the narrow Beth-horon pass leading
up to the site of Araunah (hence Aruna) the Jebusite, which became the
City of David (Zion), Jerusalem. Against the conventional view that Thutmose
III’s Mk-t-y was Megiddo, Dr. Danelius would argue, instead, that Mk-t-y
was a name for Jerusalem, (Bait-al-) Makdis. And she believed
that the Kd-šw of the Egyptian Annals was, not Kadesh in Syria,
but the land of “Har Kodsho”, “The Holy Mount”.
But it seems that there are problems with every interpretation of the
pharaoh’s route.
The road chosen by Dr. Danelius, for instance, does not go anywhere near
Taanach and Megiddo, whose coupling in the Egyptian Annals (with Taanach
perfectly transliterated in the Egyptian word, T3-‘3-n3-k3) leaves it
beyond question that the pharaonic army was bound for the strong fort of
Megiddo.
Dr. Velikovsky had fully accepted the conventional interpretation here,
that pharaoh Thutmose III’s Mk-t-y was Megiddo - but with a twist.
Pharaoh, after conquering Megiddo, Dr. Velikovsky wrote (Ages in Chaos, I,
1952), had headed southwards in pursuit of Rehoboam, “King of Kd-šw” (Kadesh =
‘the Holy’), that is, Jerusalem.
Dr. Velikovsky, to explain the conventional estimation of the Aruna
road to Megiddo, against Dr. Danelius’s very strong topographical argument,
would suggest in his response to her (as already read above) that topography
can change markedly over time: “Now as to the approach to Megiddo being a
narrow pass – by what it is now, it cannot be judged what it was almost three
thousand years ago. There could have been artificial mound-fortifications the
length of the pass”.
That, I find, to be no more compelling a view than was Dr. Danelius’s
effort to account for the Egyptian T3-‘3-n3-k3 somewhere in the region
of Jerusalem.
Dr. Velikovsky again (loc. cit.): “Your equation of Taanach with
the Tahhunah ridge does not strengthen your thesis”.
The conventional view is that the pharaoh, having arrived at Gaza (G3-d3-tw),
continued on by a coastal route, ultimately via the Wãdy ‘Ârah, to Megiddo.
After that he moved on further northwards, to conquer the troublesome
city of Kadesh on the Orontes in Syria.
The progression from Megiddo to a northern Kadesh, at least, does appear
to accord properly with the geography of the Egyptian campaign.
On this, see Patrick J. Clarke’s account in his article, “Was Jerusalem
the Kadesh of Thutmose III’s 1st Asiatic campaign? – topographic and
petrographic evidence” (Journal of Creation, Vol. 23, Issue 3, December
2011, pp. 48-55).
The standard identifications of Gaza, Taanach and Megiddo, and Kadesh on
the Orontes, seem to me now to be quite secure.
Aruna as the Wãdy
‘Ârah, however, does not!
And there is another little considered location, a town, or city, called
Yehem (Egyptian Y-hm), whose identification by convention (e.g., Petrie’s
Yemma), and by Dr. Danelius (Jamnia/Yamnia), I find not to be the least
bit convincing. “Thutmose marched his troops through the coastal pain as far as
Jamnia, then inland to Yehem, a small city near Megiddo …” (Dr. Danelius).
The typical view expressed here is just a guess.
Dr. Danelius, for her part, thought that Y-hm must be ‘Yamnia
(Yabne in Hebrew) – a port about 40 km north of Gaza’.
Neither of these two views establishes a convincing linguistic and/or
geographical connection.
Where, if anywhere, is Jerusalem in all of this?
As the disciples on another road, to Emmaus, had lamented: ‘We were
hoping …’ (Luke 24:21).
And, indeed, those inspired by Dr. Velikovsky’s Ages in Chaos
reconstructions have been hopeful that he had been able to pinpoint, in
Thutmose III’s First Campaign, his Year 22-23, his immediate march on
the glorious City of Jerusalem.
Would it not make perfect sense that the mighty pharaoh would firstly
head straight for Jerusalem once he had begun his military campaigns into
Syro-Palestine?
But now we have the Kd-šw (Kadesh) necessarily cancelled out as a
candidate for Jerusalem, it surely being Kadesh on the Orontes.
As well as this, Mk-t-y is clearly Megiddo, and not Jerusalem.
So what is there left to us?
As it now seems to me, Dr. Danelius’s Araunah for the Aruna road
can be salvaged – though not as to its precise geography.
And also her view regarding the road’s most difficult topography can be
maintained, but, once again, with geographical modifications.
Let us briefly reconstruct anew this part of Thutmose III’s campaign.
From Gaza, the pharaoh will do exactly what pharaoh Shoshenq I
(conventionally, but wrongly, identified as the biblical “Shishak”) will do in
a later period, swing across towards Jerusalem. In the case of Shoshenq I,
though, he did not actually go to Jerusalem, but to Gibeon (modern al-Jīb),
about six miles NW of Jerusalem.
(For a handy map of Shoshenq I’s campaign, see p. 41 of SIS Review,
Vol. VIII, 1986).
Pharaoh Thutmose III will make as his first place of call after Gaza a
town not given great consideration by historians, and hopelessly identified by
them: namely, Yehem (Y-hm). This Y-hm was, as I now
believe it must be, a shortened version of Jerusalem (Y-erusa-hm),
keeping in mind ancient Egyptian’s reluctant use of ‘l’ (actually missing in
their alphabet).
Y-hm, or as the Annals put it, “Yehem near Aruna”,
was obviously an important halting place, where the Egyptian army dallied,
organised supplies, and held a conference about how further to proceed.
We read an account of Yehem, for instance, as “Yaham”, in The Battle
of Megiddo by Jimmy Dunn (aka Troy Fox: www.touregypt.net):
[From Gaza the Egyptian army] reached Yaham eleven days later in mid May.
Perhaps this [now slower rate of march] indicates fatigue, or simply caution as
they travelled through territory that could be considered potentially or
actually hostile. In fact, along the way Tuthmosis III detached units commanded
by general Djehuty in order to place the stronghold of Jaffa under siege so
that his line of communication and possible retreat could be protected, an
indication that the Canaanite alliance was significant within southern Canaan.
Three possible roads from Yehem to Megiddo lay open to the Egyptians,
two of which were relatively easy to negotiate (like the conventionally chosen
way through the Wãdy ‘Ârah). One nearby road, however, was a most
difficult one, prompting the pharaoh’s officers to question: “Will the vanguard
of us be fighting while the rear is waiting here in Aruna unable to fight?”
They then provided the alternative suggestions “Now, two other roads are here,
one of the roads – behold it is to the east of us, so that it comes out at
Taanach. The other – behold, it is to the north side of Djefti, and we will
come out to the north of Megiddo”.
The Aruna road, the most difficult, but most direct, was the one
that the brilliant pharaoh chose, for a surprise assault upon Megiddo.
Jimmy Dunn writes regarding pharaoh’s tactic (op. cit.):
… the Aruna road was through a narrow and difficult pass over a ridge
that was presumed (particularly for the enemy coalition) to be too difficult
for any army to use. Taking that route meant that ‘horse must follow horse, and
man after man’….
Also, many modern commentators, and perhaps the Canaanite coalition as
well, seem to forget the major virtues of the Egyptian Chariots. They were
light vehicles, and it was certainly conceivable that many could be carried
through the pass, while the horses were led separately ….
The pass was named from its beginning at Araunah, near king Rehoboam’s
capital, Jerusalem, “Yehem near Aruna”.
Dr. Danelius had got the name right, but she had the Egyptian military
negotiating it the wrong way around, with Araunah as its destination point,
rather than its being their starting point.
This road is variously known to us today as the Way of the Patriarchs,
the Hill Road, or the Ridge Route, since it included, as we read, “a narrow and
difficult pass over a ridge”.
It was not a proper road, even as late as the time of Jesus, not one of
the international highways then to be found in Palestine. This would have been
a most tricky road, indeed, to negotiate, especially for an army that greatly
relied upon its chariots.
Conclusion
From Gaza (as all agree), Pharaoh marched to Jerusalem, Yehem (Dr.
Danelius got the general sequence right, but mis-identified Jerusalem), and
then by the treacherous Aruna road (Dr. Danelius got the name right
only, but not the direction) on to Megiddo (as per the conventional view and Dr.
Velikovsky), and then on to Syrian Kadesh (as per the conventional view and
Patrick J. Clarke).
